Top Ten List: Frozen Pizzas Ranked Worst to Best

Frozen pizza is America’s most co-dependent love affair. We buy it not because we want it, but because it’s there—waiting, cheap, patient, wedged behind a bag of freezer-burned peas like a shameful ex you keep texting. The category runs the gamut from “barely edible yoga mat” to “halfway respectable meal you might actually feed to humans.” In the interest of public safety, we ate them all. What follows is our ranking, our suffering, and our therapy bill.

10. Celeste “Pizza for One”–This isn’t pizza. It’s a damp coaster wearing ketchup. Microwave it and you’ll watch the cheese separate like a bad marriage while the crust goes limp faster than your uncle Charlie on Cialis. The only reason to buy this is if you’ve given up on life and want your groceries to match your mood.

9. Totino’s Party Pizza — “Party” here meaning the kind where someone pukes in the aquarium before midnight. Salt slaps you like an angry Sicilian grandmother. Toppings look as if they were distributed by a blindfolded Roomba. The crust resembles a stale saltine that went to finishing school. Dogs will refuse it, which is how you know it’s bad. Pair with regret and Mountain Dew Code Red.

8. DiGiorno Stuffed Crust — DiGiorno claims it’s “not delivery.” Correct, no delivery service would risk their reputation handing you this leaden dough diaper full of fake cheese ooze. (Cheese core squirts like a popped boil.) The crust doubles as an orthopedic insole, and the sauce is sweet enough to pass for pancake syrup. Pair with a will to live you no longer possess

7. Red Baron Classic Crust–The box suggests aviator swagger. The taste suggests hangar floor. It’s greasy, bland, and has the mouthfeel of a paper towel soaked in Crisco. The pepperoni tastes like it was printed on a 3D meat copier. The cheese texture resembles latex gloves at a dentist’s office. The crust behaves like plywood dipped in oil. Pair with military-grade antacid. (Still, if you close your eyes, you can pretend you’re eating it in a dorm room at 3 a.m. while someone sobs about their poli-sci exam.)

6. California Pizza Kitchen Frozen Pies–Nothing says “California” like a corporate lab tech sprinkling freeze-dried chicken over barbecue sauce that tastes like Sweet Baby Ray’s had a stroke. This over a crust that tastes like flatbread auditioning for Survivor. Pair with: kombucha and self-loathing.

5. Tombstone Original–Aptly named: it tastes like something you’d be served in the afterlife if Hell outsourced catering to middle managers. Still, it has a trashy, guilty-pleasure vibe. Think “punching down an energy drink while muttering ‘YOLO.’” The crust is weirdly chewy, like gnawing on a Nerf football. The cheese stretches reluctantly, like an overworked yoga instructor. Pair with: an expired six-pack of Busch Light.

4. Amy’s Organic Pizza–The Birkenstock of frozen pizzas: overpriced, faintly smug, and full of kale nobody asked for. The sauce whispers “namaste.” The cheese tastes like it had therapy, while the crust is basically granola in drag. But at least it tastes like real food, not NASA insulation. You can serve it to your vegan cousin without starting a family feud. Pair with: oat milk and unsolicited life advice from someone named Sage.

3. Freschetta Brick Oven–Shockingly decent. The crust pretends to be bread, the cheese melts instead of congeals, and the pepperoni won’t give you immediate heart palpitations. If you’ve ever thought, “What if frozen pizza didn’t actively insult me?”—this is your– answer. Pair with a Netflix series you don’t admit to watching.

2. Trader Joe’s Pizza Parlanno–Trader Joe’s could sell frozen drywall if they slapped a vaguely Mediterranean label on it, but here they actually deliver. Flavorful, thin-ish crust, decent toppings that don’t look like they were sneezed onto the pie, and just enough pretense to make you feel like you’re not a total goblin. Pair with $2 Chuck and smug self-satisfaction.

1. Screamin’ Sicilian–An aggressively loud name for an aggressively decent pizza. Heavy, greasy, unapologetic—like eating a mobster’s business card. The crust is chewy, hearty, almost breadlike—if bread had a drinking problem. The pepperoni is as thick as mafia gold chains, and the mustached box looks like it’s daring you to eat the whole thing alone. Best of the bunch, which is like being the tallest toddler at daycare, but still: salute. Pair with: Springsteen vinyls and your last shred of dignity.

If listicles are your bag, visit our top-ten lists archive and fill your boots.